SPECIAL MEETING OF THE CHARLOTTESVILLE CITY COUNCIL
NOTICE OF SPECIAL MEETING
A SPECIAL MEETING OF THE CHARLOTTESVILLE CITY COUNCIL WILL BE
HELD ON Monday, March 5, 2012, AT 6:30 p.m. IN THE Second Floor Conference
THE PROPOSED AGENDA IS AS FOLLOWS:
Closed session as provided by Section 2.2-3712 of the Virginia Code
BY ORDER OF THE MAYOR BY Paige Barfield
SECOND FLOOR CONFERENCE ROOM – March 5, 2012
Council met in special session on this date with the following members present:
Ms. Galvin, Mr. Huja, Mr. Norris, Ms. Szakos.
On motion by Ms. Galvin, seconded by Mr. Norris, Council voted, (Ayes: Ms.
Galvin, Mr. Huja, Mr. Norris, Ms. Szakos; Noes: None; Absent: Ms. Smith), to meet in
closed session for discussion and consideration of appointments to City boards and
commissions, as authorized by Virginia Code sec. 2.2-3711 (A) (1).
On motion by Ms. Galvin, seconded by Mr. Norris, Council certified by the
following vote (Ayes: Ms. Galvin, Mr. Huja, Mr. Norris, Ms. Szakos; Noes: None;
Absent: Ms. Smith), that to the best of each Council Member's knowledge, only public
business matters lawfully exempted from the open meeting requirements of the Virginia
Freedom of Information Act and identified in the motion convening the closed session
were heard, discussed or considered in the closed session.
COUNCIL CHAMBERS – March 5, 2012
Council met in regular session on this date with the following members present:
Ms. Galvin, Mr. Huja, Mr. Norris, and Ms. Szakos. Ms. Smith was absent.
Mr. Huja presented the Distinguished Budget award to Ms. Beauregard for FY
Mr. Huja presented a proclamation for Festival of the Book to Ms. Nancy Damon.
Ms. Damon thanked Council for their support and asked citizens to go to their website,
www.vabook.org, for more information about the festival.
Mr. Jones recognized Chief Charles Warner for receiving the 2011 Governor’s
Fire Service Award for Excellence in Fire Service Management. Chief Warner thanked
Council for their recognition and members of City staff for their teamwork.
Mr. Norris announced the City will co-sponsor the Charlottesville Honor Ride
event on April 5th. For more information and to enroll in this year’s ride, go to
cvillehonorride.blogspot.com, or email email@example.com, or call (434) 242-
Ms. Szakos announced Council’s budget work session next Monday, March 12th
and the Sprout Film Festival March 9th. She also announced upcoming Celebrate!250
events. Go to www.celebrate250.com for more information
MATTERS BY THE PUBLIC
Ms. Colette Hall, 101 Robertson Ln., said balancing the City budget is the most
important duty Council has. She asked Council to hold the schools to task and make
tough cuts so they can stay within their budget.
Ms. Erin Rose, 1790 Bundoran Dr. in North Garden, presented a petition for a
referendum for the right of the public to have a say in the sale of water rights. She said
Council should not approve the contract until they know the price tag.
Ms. Nancy Carpenter, 727 Denali Way, said she supports the UVA Living Wage
campaign. She also said she supported the students and Northwestern High School to
protest the cuts in education funding and teacher positions. She thanked City Council for
their vision with The Crossings facility and asked if we can do more.
Mr. Brandon Collins, 536 Meade Ave., also thanked Council for their support of
The Crossings project. He asked Council to think about projects that cover supportive
housing for entire families. He said he supported the UVA Living Wage campaign, and
he thanked Ms. Szakos and Mr. Norris for their support of the campaign. He asked
Council to increase the base wage to $13 and hour and tie it to the cost of living.
Mr. Galen Staengl, 129 Goodman St., encouraged Council to continue the
discussion about the Belmont Bridge and urban design of the associated areas. He said
Council should ask for more information about chloramines in the drinking water and the
hazards associated with byproducts.
Mr. Jim Rounsevell, 1113 Monticello Rd., said he is a registered architect in
Virginia and has been very involved in the bridge project. He supports Council’s call for
further research; the public does not support the current bridge design. The bridge should
be more than just a replacement; there must be design. Council should take ownership of
the process and fund it.
Ms. Heather Higgins, 703 Graves St., of Bike Charlottesville, thanked Council for
their ongoing efforts to create a world-class bike-friendly city. She requested Council
steer the bridge process to prioritize bike and pedestrian friendliness. For more
information, go to completestreets.org and nacdo.org and use the available information to
create a solution.
Mr. Brevy Cannon, 710 Ridge St., said there was great participation in the
Belmont Bridge design competition, and Council should capture good ideas and harness
creativity to get us to the right design. He suggested a design committee to include local
design professionals, UVA faculty, and representatives from Belmont and adjacent
neighborhoods. He will forward Council a list of people who would be willing to serve
on such a committee.
Mr. Robert Smith said the process of calling for design after the project got
started was backwards. Council should use the new installment as an opportunity to
make a connection between downtown and Belmont.
COUNCIL RESPONSES TO MATTERS BY THE PUBLIC
Ms. Szakos thanked Ms. Hall for coming. The school efficiency audit suggested
closing one school. The schools have been working hard to do that, but it is expensive
and we do not yet have the money. Almost every other implementation in that report has
been done. The deficit is not because of mismanagement; the state has withdrawn its
funding every year. We have increased our percentage of support to ensure the schools
are funded at an excellent level.
Ms. Galvin thanked Ms. Szakos for her comments about the public schools. She
said she served on the School Board when the management efficiency study was
conducted, and the board did try to implement the school closing suggestion, but could
not do so in the face of tough economic times. She thanked Ms. Carpenter and Mr.
Collins for their support of housing, which Council will discuss comprehensively later in
the agenda. She agreed that urban design is an important component to the neighborhood
south of the downtown mall.
Mr. Norris thanked Ms. Hall for reminding Council of their duty to be fiscally
responsible. He thanked the 300 plus people who signed the petition regarding the
Ragged Mountain Natural Area. He said looking at housing in a comprehensive fashion is
important, and he also supports the Living Wage movement. He agreed with Mr. Collins
that we need more transitional housing for families. He said he was blindsided by the
issue of the chloramines and said it might be helpful for Mr. Frederick to come to a
Council meeting and explain more about the project. He thanked everyone who spoke on
the Belmont bridge and related issues.
Mr. Huja thanked citizens for their comments about the Belmont bridge. He said
it is an important gateway to our community and needs to be designed well. Doing away
with the bridge is impractical. He corrected a citizen who claimed Nestle was involved,
saying the grant was never awarded.
On motion by Mr. Norris, seconded by Ms. Galvin, the following appointments
were made to the Human Rights taskforce: Michelle Bates, Jesse Ellis, Susan Erno,
Harvey Finkel, Andrea Hakes, Simona J. Holloway-Warren, Tim Hulburt, Dorenda
Johnson, Lena Jones, Richard Jones, Edward Strickler. (Ayes: Ms. Galvin, Mr. Huja, Mr.
Norris, Ms. Szakos; Noes: None; Absent: Ms. Smith),
On motion by Ms. Szakos, seconded by Ms. Galvin, the following consent agenda
items were approved: (Ayes: Ms. Galvin, Mr. Huja, Mr. Norris, Ms. Szakos; Noes: None;
Absent: Ms. Smith),
a. Minutes of February 21 and February 24
b. APPROPRIATION: Albemarle County Reimbursement for Preston/Morris
Building Envelope Restoration - $1,426.28 (carried)
c. APPROPRIATION: Albemarle County Reimbursement for CATEC Monument
Sign - $2,301.50 (carried)
d. APPROPRIATION: Albemarle County Reimbursement for Gordon Avenue
Library Elevator/Restroom - $25,232.84 (carried)
e. APPROPRIATION: Albemarle County Reimbursement for CATEC Bus Loop -
f. APPROPRIATION: Albemarle County Reimbursement for Central Library
McIntire Room - $487.50 ) carried (carried)
g. APPROPRIATION: Albemarle County Reimbursement - Gordon Avenue
Library-Building Envelope (Masonry) - $1,368.78 (carried)
h. RESOLUTION: Arlington & Millmont Apartments SUP for Increased
Density and Height
i. ORDINANCE: Retirement Commission (carried)
j. ORDINANCE: Conveyance of Right of Way at Church Street (2nd
REPORT: SCHOOL BOARD’S PROPOSED FY 2013 BUDGET
Mr. Gillespie and Ms. Atkins presented to Council on the School Board’s
proposed budget for FY 2013, which was approved by the School Board on March 1st
Ms. Atkins highlighted the school division’s accomplishments last year and reviewed the
strategic plan for 2011-2017.
Mr. Gillespie reviewed School Division General Fund Financial Statistics since
2009, including enrollment increases, state budget reductions, and cuts to services. He
reviewed the total negative impact from the Governor’s Proposed Budget for 2012-13,
budget meetings to date, and the 2012-13 total budget.
Mr. Norris thanked Mr. Gillespie and Ms. Atkins for their presentation and
thanked staff and the School Board for their work in devising a budget during a difficult
year. He asked them how they plan not to request one-time money next year. Ms. Atkins
said they cannot promise that, but they have given the board three levels of cuts to
examine as the FY14 school year approaches. The board is looking to market the school
division and make it a more attractive place for students to come. Mr. Gillespie said
anything Council can do to make it clear to the state that these cuts are not acceptable
would be helpful. Ms. Szakos said even though the state is not supporting education, she
will let our schools become negatively impacted. She asked citizens to support political
candidates who support schools. Ms. Galvin said we should work together with the
county, and we are willing to get back to the negotiating table locally. Ms. Atkins said
Mr. Michie sent an email inviting the Board of Supervisors, City Council, and the
Albemarle School Board to talk about reuniting a spirit of collaboration in which we can
share services for efficiency. He is awaiting their response. Mr. Huja said he is
appreciative of our good school system and hopes a cooperative committee can be
REPORT: CITY MANAGER’S PROPOSED FY 2013 BUDGET
Mr. Jones presented to Council on the proposed FY 2012-13 Operating and
Capital budget. He thanked staff and the CIP Staff Ranking Committee for their work.
He reviewed three themes for the year: strong support for City schools, quality services
for the citizens of Charlottesville, and maintaining the tax rate at .95. He reviewed the
2011 citizen budget survey, budget highlights, including changes in the general fund
budget over the last ten years, the FY 2013 General fund revenues, and revenue
projections. Areas of concern include state budget impacts on 2013 general fund
expenditures, state funding of education. The City is funding $3.4 million in new money
to the schools. Mr. Jones reviewed compensation and benefits and living wage issues,
which will be discussed at the work session next Monday night. The FY 2012 CIP was
about maintaining what we have in place, rather than adding new projects. Looking
ahead, state funding of our schools will be a major capital need. Staff is positive about
declining unemployment, and sales, meals and lodging taxes trending upwards. We have
maintained our AAA bond rating. All budget information can be found online at the City
Ms. Szakos encouraged the public to attend the work sessions. Mr. Norris thanked
Mr. Jones, Ms. Beauregard, and staff for putting together a solid proposal. Ms. Galvin
thanked staff for making an intense and complicated operation clear. Mr. Huja said staff
has done an excellent job in putting together the budget and challenged citizens to take
part in the budget process.
REPORT: ANNUAL HOUSING REPORT
Mr. Tolbert presented to Council. He gave an overview of their 2025 goal, which
is to increase the ratio of supported affordable units to 15% of total housing units by
2025. He updated Council on progress since the initial 2025 report, including hiring a
housing development specialist and collaboration between CRHA and NDS. He
reviewed affordable housing investments, including 60 new units at the SRO at 4th and
Preston, donation of City property at The Woods on the south side of Elliott Avenue, the
Nunley townhouses, Timberlake Place, and Sunrise Park. He discussed leveraged funds,
reviewed other initiatives, future directions and efforts, and reviewed conclusions,
including a shift towards funding for building housing, instead of social programs.
Mr. Norris asked about vouchers for Blue Ridge Commons. Mr. Tolbert said
ultimately those may well be taken out into the community, which will increase our
number of supportive housing units. Mr. Norris asked about status of the report
commissioned through JABA. Mr. Tolbert said staff will send an update to Council next
Ms. Galvin said it is great to see the annual report and recommended pinning
down the definition of “affordable housing”. She asked that the CAAR project regarding
workforce housing be reexamined. Ms. Szakos said other communities have done
general contracting for affordable housing work, and it would be helpful to examine why
this works. Ms. Galvin asked if the area on Cleveland was already a low income area and
requested that staff examine other areas that are of a higher income level in order to avoid
concentrating poverty. Mr. Tolbert said this is a goal, but it is a struggle because land
availability is predominantly on the south side of town. Mr. Huja said he is pleased that
we are proceeding to build houses and hopes this will move forward more quickly. The
report would benefit from a map.
Mr. Norris said staff tried to define affordable housing in the 2025 report. Ms.
Szakos said the City is actually more affordable than surrounding areas when you
consider the cost of fuel. Ms. Galvin said she was excited to see a much more
REPORT/RESOLUTION: URBAN DESIGN/ECONOMIC PLAN FOR AREAS
SOUTH OF RAILROAD TRACKS
Mr. Tolbert presented to Council on finding a way to examine the area of town
near the Belmont Bridge to examine possible urban design and examine redevelopment
issues. Staff proposed assembling an RFP for urban design, economic development
analysis and planning, and the urban form. We need to move forward with development
of the Levy site and Crescent Halls, but more work with the community is needed on
what those projects will look like. Staff proposes using $150,000 from CRHA sites to
complete work upfront and immediately. This plan is heavily dependent on the
involvement of the community, residents of public housing, and the surrounding
community. This money is not specifically for the bridge.
Ms. Szakos said by taking money for this study from redevelopment funds, she is
concerned about including the Martha Jefferson area, which seems to imply that some of
the redevelopment housing will be put in that area. Mr. Tolbert said the line is drawn to
recognize that a lot of jobs will be generated from that site, so it is an area that needs to
be included as a connection. Ms. Szakos said she wants to ensure we do not take money
from public housing and section A housing to divert it to a general planning process.
Ms. Galvin said if we include the Martha Jefferson area, she is concerned we are
stretching our monies too thin. We could be looking at two study areas, and we should
not combine them. Council suggested using a dotted line around the Martha Jefferson
Mr. Norris said he agreed with Ms. Galvin that this land area is much bigger than
he anticipated and asked if we are spreading money too thinly. Ms. Galvin said this was
the area that was included in the Choice Neighborhood Grant, and this defines a walkable
neighborhood. Mr. Tolbert said one reason staff drew the line so far south was to include
First Street. Mr. Norris said he hopes we are learning from the lessons of the design
competition, which is that the bridge encompasses the surrounding areas.
On motion by Ms. Galvin, seconded by Ms. Szakos, the resolution passed, with
the amended map. (Ayes: Ms. Galvin, Mr. Huja, Mr. Norris, Ms. Szakos; Noes: None;
Absent: Ms. Smith)
REPORT/RESOLUTION: PLACEMAKING, LIVABILITY, AND COMMUNITY
ENGAGEMENT (PLACE) DESIGN TASK FORCE
Mr. Tolbert presented to Council. The City had an Urban Design Committee,
which dissolved in 2003. PLACE Design Task Force is intended to serve in a similar
capacity and would advise the Planning Commission and City Council. Mr. Tolbert
outlined the proposed composition of the task force. This group would have been helpful
in the Belmont Bridge process.
Ms. Galvin said a group like this would have also been helpful with the Woolen
Mills pump station. This does not take the place of a neighborhood-based steering
committee and is not intended to extend or add another layer of discretionary review, but
to help provide input and guidance. Mr. Huja said this would improve the quality of
design in our community. Mr. Norris said this may ultimately help streamline some
projects, creating standards everyone is clear on. Ms. Szakos said we are lucky to have
two people with expertise in City planning on Council.
On motion by Ms. Szakos, seconded by Mr. Norris, the resolution passed. (Ayes:
Ms. Galvin, Mr. Huja, Mr. Norris, Ms. Szakos; Noes: None; Absent: Ms. Smith)
REPORT/RESOLUTION: BUSINESS ACTIVITY POLICY FOR PARKS &
Mr. Daly presented to Council on an updated policy regarding business activities
in Parks and Recreation facilities, which would provide groups and individuals the ability
to conduct business activities at City facilities within certain guidelines. The fee was
adjusted to 6% to be consistent with vendor fees at the City market. A twenty-day
timeline for application review was established.
Mr. Huja asked if twenty days was necessary for a review process. Mr. Daly said
proposed activities could conflict with existing activities, and some negotiations may
need to take place. Twenty days would be the maximum amount of time to return a
Ms. Szakos clarified that activity on parkland was covered by this policy. Ms.
Davies said that providing service on parkland, regardless of where you advertise, is
covered by the policy.
On motion by Ms. Szakos, seconded by Ms. Galvin, the resolution passed. (Ayes:
Ms. Galvin, Mr. Huja, Mr. Norris, Ms. Szakos; Noes: None; Absent: Ms. Smith)
OTHER BUSINESS: BELMONT BRIDGE PROCESS UPDATE
Mr. Norris asked for an update of where the Belmont Bridge process stands. Mr.
Tolbert said staff will take information from the competition and instill what could be
used for the design process. Mr. Tolbert’s design team, the bike/pedestrian coordinator,
the MMM Engineering Firm, and the Chair of the UVA School of Architecture will meet
and discuss how to include those ideas. The engineering firm will engage a local
architect to work with their design team. The design will incorporate the most
appropriate elements that are produced from collaboration. PLACE will be the public
sounding body initially. Mr. Norris requested that community members be involved.
MATTERS BY THE PUBLIC
Ms. Nancy Carpenter, 727 Denali Way, said she is going to the Albemarle County
meeting on the comprehensive plan and was pleased with tonight’s updates.
Mr. Jim Rounsevell, 1113 Monticello Rd., said the bridge process should remain
open and transparent.